Anna Maria Island Florida Restaurants with Meals Under $20
- Nancy McAleer
- Dec 23, 2025
- 7 min read
Dec 23, 2025
Eating well on Anna Maria Island doesn’t have to come with a big price tag. From taco joints and beach cafés to burger scks and casual seafood spots, the island is full of relaxed restaurants where you can enjoy a satisfying meal for around $20 or less per person. This is it! 20 budget-friendly dining options that visitors love. Enjoy our list of Anna Maria Island, Florida Restaurants with Meals Under $20. Perfect for keeping your vacation delicious and affordable.
Use our interactive map below on Google to help you set your itinerary for the best Anna Maria Island Restaurants with meals under twenty dollars - $20.
🌮 1. Poppo’s Taqueria – Fresh, Fast Island Tacos
⭐ Google Rating: 4.6
📍 Map: Poppo’s Taqueria, Anna Maria Island
Poppo’s is one of the island’s most popular casual dining spots. It tops the list of one of our absolute faves! Known for fresh ingredients and bold flavors. Their tacos, burritos, bowls, and quesadillas are filling and customizable, making it easy to stay within budget. It’s perfect for a quick lunch or a low-key dinner after a beach day, especially for families and groups.
Poppo's Taqueria is located on the north end of the island around the corner from our awesome Anna Maria Island vacation rentals. Our kids love taking the golf cart to fill their taco addition.
Insider Tip!
Although it's not on the menu. We make our own nachos by ordering a small bowl full of delicious fixings like beef, black beans, guacamole, pico de gallo, sour cream, cilantro and more. Along with a freshly made basket of tortilla chips. Just dump the bowl over the basket of chips and voila. You've got your fix of nachos!
You can also order up online and pick it up at the restaurant to take out.
🍔 2. Skinny’s Place – Old-School Island Burgers
⭐ Google Rating: 4.5
📍 Map: Skinny’s Place, Holmes Beach
Skinny’s Place is a longtime local favorite that keeps things simple and satisfying. Known for juicy burgers, crispy fries, and cold drinks, this laid-back burger shack offers generous portions at wallet-friendly prices. The casual picnic-table setting gives you a true island vibe without the tourist markup. Don't be intimidated by the exterior appearance of this burger dive. The food is delicious and the beer is cold!
☕ 3. Ginny’s & Jane E’s Café – Breakfast & Lunch with Personality
⭐ Google Rating: 4.7
📍 Map: Ginny’s & Jane E’s Café, Anna Maria
This quirky café and gift shop combo is a Pine Avenue staple. Ginny’s & Jane E’s serves hearty breakfasts, creative lunch sandwiches, salads, and baked goods, most well under $20. The fun décor and relaxed atmosphere make it a must-stop for visitors wanting a unique island experience. The cinnamon buns are bigger than you head! Great value for the money.
🥪 4. Scott’s Deli – Big Sandwiches, Small Prices
⭐ Google Rating: 4.7
📍 Map: Scott’s Deli, Holmes Beach
Scott’s Deli is perfect for grab-and-go lunches or beach picnics. Their sandwiches, wraps, and salads are stacked high and made fresh to order. It’s an easy way to feed hungry beachgoers without spending much, and locals swear by the quality and consistency. We grab a bunch of sandwiches and head out on the boat for a day of fun on a sandbar nearby. Easy and so yummy!
🏖️ 5. Anna Maria Island Beach Café – Toes-in-the-Sand Dining
⭐ Google Rating: 4.5
📍 Map: Anna Maria Island Beach Café
Located directly on Manatee Public Beach, this café is ideal for a casual meal with a view. Breakfast plates, burgers, sandwiches, and seafood baskets are reasonably priced, especially for beachfront dining. It’s a relaxed, no-rush spot that fits perfectly into a beach day.
Try their "All You Can Eat Pancakes". If you know... you know! This special treat at Maria Island Beach Cafe is a must when visiting AMI. Fluffy stacks, sausage on the side, and breakfast with your toes in the sand. It truly doesn’t get better than this.
🍤 6. Kiwi Style Fish & Chips – Casual Seafood Done Right
⭐ Google Rating: 4.8
📍 Map: Kiwi Style Fish & Chips, Holmes Beach
This small, no-frills restaurant delivers authentic fish and chips with generous portions. Crispy, flavorful, and filling, it’s one of the best budget seafood options on the island. Ideal for lunch or a simple dinner when you’re craving something classic.
🍗 7. gRub Tropical BBQ – Island-Style Comfort Food
⭐ Google Rating: 4.6
📍 Map: gRub Tropical BBQ, Anna Maria
gRub offers bold flavors with a laid-back island twist. BBQ sandwiches, bowls, and plates provide great value and generous portions. Located on Pine Avenue, it’s a fun and casual stop that works well for lunch or an early dinner.
🍺 8. Slim’s Place – Laid-Back Bar & Grill Favorites
⭐ Google Rating: 4.2
📍 Map: Slim’s Place, Anna Maria
Slim’s Place is a relaxed neighborhood bar serving burgers, wings, wraps, and pub classics. Prices are reasonable, the atmosphere is friendly, and it’s a great place to unwind after a long beach day without overspending. It's one of the best spots to catch a sports event on the island too.
🍕 9. Pizza Social – Easy Island Pizza Nights
⭐ Google Rating: 4.7
📍 Map: Pizza Social, Anna Maria
Pizza Social is a great choice for families and groups. Their pizzas, salads, and shareable plates are affordable and filling. It’s perfect for nights when you want something casual, easy, and crowd-pleasing. It's our favorite first night meal on the island for check-in day. Don't miss out on their delish garlic knots dipped in garlic butter. Yummmm.
🍔 10. Harry’s Grill – Quick, Casual Comfort Food
⭐ Google Rating: 4.2
📍 Map: Harry’s Grill, Anna Maria
Harry’s Grill keeps things simple with burgers, sandwiches, and classic American fare. It’s a convenient stop near Pine Avenue and beach access, making it an easy choice for visitors looking for a quick, affordable meal. They have a lovely outdoor area which is fab year round.
🌮 11. Hurricane Hanks – Something for Everyone
⭐ Google Rating: 4.5
📍 Map: Hurricane Hanks, Holmes Beach
Hurricane Hanks offers a wide-ranging menu with plenty of lunch specials and casual dinner options under $20. From sandwiches and tacos to burgers and lighter seafood dishes, it’s a dependable choice for mixed groups and families.
🐟 12. The Ugly Grouper – Fun, Family-Friendly Island Eats
⭐ Google Rating: 4.6
📍 Map: The Ugly Grouper, Holmes Beach
Known for its lively atmosphere and outdoor seating, The Ugly Grouper serves tacos, burgers, fish baskets, and casual plates that are generous and budget-friendly. Live music and a relaxed vibe make it a favorite for vacation nights.
This is a great spot to take young children. There are plenty of outdoor games that will occupy young ones while you wait for your dinner. The gigantic Ugly Grouper is an iconic instagram-able moment.
🍦 13. Two Scoops – More Than Just Ice Cream
⭐ Google Rating: 4.7
📍 Map: Two Scoops, Anna Maria
While famous for ice cream, Two Scoops also serves breakfast items, bagels, hot dogs, and simple lunches. It’s an affordable and convenient stop for the whole family and dessert is already covered. We love the grilled cheese sandwiches and chilli cheese dogs. Two Scoops is a definite must-visit on AMI.
☕ 14. Cool Beans AMI – Light Bites & Smoothies
⭐ Google Rating: 4.5
📍 Map: Cool Beans AMI, Anna Maria
Cool Beans is ideal for breakfast, coffee, or a lighter lunch. Smoothies, wraps, and breakfast sandwiches are fresh, filling, and easy on the budget. This stop is perfect for fueling up before a beach day. We like their avocado toast and smoothies!
🌴 15. Island Time Bar & Grill – Casual Vacation Vibes
⭐ Google Rating: 4.2
📍 Map: Island Time Bar & Grill, Holmes Beach
This relaxed spot serves burgers, tacos, sandwiches, and comfort food favorites. Prices are reasonable, portions are solid, and the laid-back atmosphere fits perfectly with island life. They often host bands and deejays at night. The dance floor turns into a hot spot on the island.
🍗 16. D Coy Ducks Bar & Grille – Local Favorite Comfort Food
⭐ Google Rating: 4.2
📍 Map: D Coy Ducks Bar & Grille, Holmes Beach
Popular with locals, D Coy Ducks offers wings, burgers, wraps, and daily specials that won’t break the bank. It’s a great choice if you want a casual evening out close to your rental. It's centrally located in the Holmes Beach Plaza which is easy to get to from anywhere on the island.
🦪 17. AMI Oyster Bar – Casual Seafood Options
⭐ Google Rating: 4.5
📍 Map: AMI Oyster Bar, Holmes Beach
While oysters can add up, AMI Oyster Bar also offers sandwiches, tacos, and lunch specials that fit comfortably under $20. The relaxed vibe makes it approachable for visitors wanting seafood without upscale prices.
We love the location on historic Bridge Street Pier. The outdoor dining looks out onto the Intercoastal Waterway on Anna Maria Sound. The fried shrimp and a cool iced tea are perfect on a hot, sunny day while watching the boats sail by.
🥗 18. North Shore Café – Fresh & Simple Island Eats
⭐ Google Rating: 4.2
📍 Map: North Shore Café, Anna Maria
North Shore Café is a cozy spot offering breakfast and lunch with fresh ingredients and friendly service. Sandwiches, salads, and breakfast plates make it a great low-key, affordable option.
Our family loves the acai bowls for breakfast. Get there early! This is a popular spot for breakfast on the island.
🐖 19. Smoqehouse – Flavorful BBQ and Sandwiches Without the Price Tag
⭐ Google Rating: 4.7
📍 Map: Smoqehouse, Bradenton Beach
Craving bold barbecue flavors without spending a lot? Smoqehouse is a casual, island-friendly spot known for hearty portions and big, smoky taste at reasonable prices. The menu features a variety of smoked and flame-grilled meats served in sandwiches, wraps, and satisfying plates. Enjoy favorites like brisket, pulled pork, and jerk-style chicken. It’s a relaxed place to grab lunch or dinner, especially after a day at the beach, with food that’s filling, flavorful, and easy on the vacation budget.
🥯 20. Paradise Bagels & Café – Easy Breakfast & Lunch
⭐ Google Rating: 4.1
📍 Map: Paradise Bagels & Café, Holmes Beach
Paradise Bagels is perfect for quick breakfasts and casual lunches. Bagels, breakfast sandwiches, and deli-style options are filling, affordable, and convenient for busy vacation mornings.
🌞 Final Tip for Visitors looking for Restaurant Meals Under $20
Mixing in a few of these budget-friendly restaurants can significantly reduce vacation dining costs. Anna Maria Island Restaurants with Meals under $20 leaves more room for beach days, sunset cruises, and island adventures.
We hope you find our list helpful in your next vacation planning adventure to Anna Maria Island.
__________________________________
WHERE TO STAY
Anna Maria Island Home Rental
At Anna Maria Island Home Rental, we have luxurious waterfront accommodations. Enjoy a fabulous family getaway to your favorite Florida island. We specialize in exceeding customer expectations, with backyard beaches, docks, outting greens, tiki huts, hammocks, and so much more!
Contact us for information and a detailed quote!
