anna maria island





  • Nancy McAleer

The Top 5 Pizza SmackDown on AMI

The Great Pizza SmackDown begins!

North Americans love their pizza and let's face it, it's an easy, inexpensive and healthy meal for the whole family. If you're visiting Anna Maria Island, Florida and want Insider information on the best pizza on the island, you're in for a treat.

We have listed our top, favorite pizzeria's on the island where you can't go wrong. We are by no means the experts but we do LOVE GOOD FOOD, so here's hoping we will do you proud.

Pizza Smackdown - Anna Maria Island

# 1

Vinny & Cheryl's Italian Kitchen

314 Pine Avenue, Anna Maria 941-896-9754

This pizza is robust with authentic flavours. Generous portions and a crushed tomato sauce that transports us back to Italy. You can tell that the dough is made by an Italian chef because the crust is the perfect balance between crispy and soft on the inside. The cheese is real mozzarella that has a creamy texture. Made fresh daily in a wood burning oven for take out only. It tops our SmackDown list !

wood fired pizza

Insider Icon - pink seahorse

Insider Tip:

Vinny & Cheryl's is a take-out only restaurant. Make sure you order your pizza early and pick it up by 6:30 pm. Give the chef in your group a break and eat your pizza wile dining al fresco at your vacation rental's backyard oasis.

# 2

Fire & Stone Pizza

10519 Cortez Rd West, Bradenton


By far the pies at Fire & Stone Pizza are the best value in town. The Endless Artisan Pizza Bar has over 500 delicious combinations to choose from. The crust is thin and light and crispy. The friendly staff keep the pizza pies coming out hot and fresh, as fast as we can eat them! With all day buffet prices of $8.99 and $5.50 for children under 7, it fits the bill when trying to stretch your dollar. We rate Fire & Stone Number 2 on our list.

meat lover's pizza

Insider Tip Icon - Pink Seahorse

Insider Tip:

Fire & Stone Pizza is located off island, but it's just over the bridge. It's a short drive but great for a family on a budget!

# 3

The Feast's Pizza

5406 Marina Drive, Holmes Beach


The Feast's pizza is guaranteed Hand tossed only using the freshest ingredients. What we love about this pizza is the sauce. They have over 27 different toppings to choose from! Ranging from peas.... yes I said peas... to traditional toppings like feta cheese and eggplant. The Feast thinks outside the box when they talk pizza. They also offer signature pizza's like White Pizza, Pretty Tasty, Mighty Meaty and The Works. Pizza are offered in 14 or 16 inch sizes. Prices range from $15.50 - 20.00. A definite yes on our list!

Insider Tip Icon - Pink Seahorse

Insider Tip:

The Feast Restaurant is located on Marina Drive right next to the Free Trolley Stop.... very handy and no designated driver required!

# 4

Oma's Pizza

201 Gulf Drive North, Bradenton Beach


With two types of crust to choose from Hand Tossed or Inch Thick Sicilian crust, this pie is at it's best while eaten outdoors with the beautiful view. A family owned business that has been a staple on the island for years. The sauce is not too spicy and the portions generous. You will probably have leftovers. We hear the calzones are good too. Oma's rounds out Number 3 on our Pizza SmackDown list.

gourmet pizza

Insider Tip Icon - Pink Seahorse

Insider Tip:

Oma's is located towards the southern end of the island, so if you are ordering delivery it may arrive at your vacation rental a bit soggy. Best bet is to eat in the restaurant or pick it up yourself.

# 5

J Burn's Pizza

308 Pine Avenue, Anna Maria


J Burn's Pizza is not for everyone. This may not start out as a great review but I have to tell you I really like their pizza. Here's why... It's a super thin crust cut into really small squares. It's great for feeding smaller kids. I can eat a ton of those little pizza squares with the cornmeal underneath and a light topping it's perfect for a lunch-time treat. Pizzas range in sizes from 7, 12 to 16 inches. Prices from $5.75 - 19.25

J Burns Pizza

J Burns Pizza

Insider Icon - Pink Seahorse

Insider Tip:

Join their loyalty program and earn $5 off for every $50 you spend.

To join, text "REWARDS" to 863-877-4792.

Let us know if we have done you proud, or if we missed another great pizzeria on the island that deserves to be included on our Pizza SmackDown list. We hope you find the pizza that you are dreaming of on Anna Maria Island. Bon Appetito!

Contact us for luxury accommodations on beautiful Anna Maria Island, Florida

Anna Maria Island Home Rental

Dining Outdoors at Sirenia By The Sea Vacation Rental

Contact us button
Anna Maria Island Home Rental Icon

Like this story?

Feel free to share it on your social media

by clicking one of the buttons below.


#restaurants #annamariaisland #vacation #vacationrentalsannamariaisland #annamariaislandvacationrentals #florida #bradentonbeach #holmesbeach

640 views0 comments





Sign up for our newsletter

  • Facebook Basic Square
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest Social Icon
  • Twitter Basic Square
  • YouTube Social  Icon

Have a question or want to collaborate? Contact me for further information. 


Some links on Anna Maria Island Beach Life may be affiliate links. For my full disclosure and privacy policy please click here.


Feel free to PIN any image from Anna Maria Island Beach Life Blog or Anna Maria Island Home Rental. 

Do not repurpose, repost, or redistribute articles (partial or fully) without written permission. 

If you would like to feature my work, you may share 1 photo from a post if it is clearly linked back to my original post, for the sole purpose of featuring my Blog or Vacation Rentals. 

DO NOT USE my articles and RSS feeds in their entirety as your own. All photos and posts are copyright protected.