About Us

Instead of us bragging about ourselves, how about we let our guests do the talking for us?


"Nancy and Terri were great to deal with and are very concerned with making your vacation stay at Sirenia Beach House the best it can be!!! Loved it!!!"


"The owners provided absolutely outstanding customer service and always responded promptly to emails. Nancy went above and beyond while helping me plan for our wedding..... Absolutely perfect!"


"The homeowners could not have been any better to work with and I would not hesitate to rent this home again or recommend it to others. Was a perfect place to reconnect with family and watch my children grow. Thanks for sharing your home!!"


First off let me say that Nancy and Terri, were amazing people to rent from. Very friendly, accommodating, and fast to respond to emails, or calls. As for the property, it exceeded our expectations.


Excellent...owners have spared no expense in making this the best yet!! 

Who are we?

We are 2 close families that decided to take the plunge into Paradise together. Yes, that's us with the Stanley Cup during the NHL Playoffs, we really need to get a better photo up of all of us together! 


The story starts with early retirement in 2010 ~ actually, the recession helped with that. When you lose your job, the next best thing is to buy a vacation home right??? Well, we are the crazy families who made the leap to do just that. It was time to listen to that little voice in our heads and re-group, breathe and lead a saner life of slowing down and reconnecting with our families. 


We decided to vacation to Anna Maria Island in 2011 to search for a beach house and immediately fell in love with Anna Maria! What’s not to love about the authentic Florida beautiful beaches, great restaurants, boating, and the Islanders themselves? Our favorite activity while vacationing is to rent a boat and sail to a private island passing the day away shelling & snorkeling. We have young families and love that the Island is very close to Disney, Busch Gardens, Mote Marine Laboratory as well as the major sporting events in nearby Tampa... Go Bolts! Yes, we are hockey fans. 

We love the fact that Anna Maria is extremely laid back without an attitude and safe!


Buying our first property, which my husband lovingly referred to as a "dump", we furiously went about renovations inside and out to create an oasis where both families could vacation together. We really focused on what we wanted as renters. Jump forward 10 years later and we now own 3 gorgeous homes on the island that we love sharing with other families who are also dreaming of an authentic Florida experience. 

Why you can feel confident booking with us!


"The husbands" work in the background, and Terri and I (Nancy) work with the guests looking for an island escape. Terri has extensive knowledge of the travel and resort industry from her time spent with Club Med, as well as a strong financial background from working in financial institutions within Canada. My background as a former director of a major retailer, consulting, and facilitation certification helps me offer outstanding customer service to ensure your vacation dreams are reached. That little voice has never left us and we continue to listen to our clients in order to improve and offer what we consider to be THE BEST VACATION EXPERIENCE on Anna Maria Island. 


We are proud to be members of the AMIVPA (Anna Maria Island Vacation Property Association). A group of ethical and responsible property owners and managers, working towards a balanced vacation rental industry on Anna Maria Island. We strongly support the Best Practices Guidelines and do our best to educate visitors on noise, parking, trash ordinances, and wildlife preservation through our direct communications as well as reaching a larger community through our social media sites. 


We love giving back to the community through our donations to "Save The Manatee", as well as, food and furniture donations to local charities. We recommend visitors also donate their unopened, non-perishable food to the local food banks, or our hard-working staff at the end of their stay, to feel good about giving back to the paradise that they visit.

Our Mission


Our goal is to create a luxurious tropical ambiance where vacation memories are cherished on beautiful Anna Maria Island, Florida. We are here to assist you in making that possible whether celebrating a wedding, honeymoon, family reunion, or a much-needed stress-free vacation!

Our luxury Anna Maria Island waterfront vacation rentals are your home away from home and waiting for you! 


Feel free to contact us today.


Kind Regards,

Nancy McAleer

  • Wix Facebook page
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest Classic
  • YouTube Classic
  • Twitter Classic
  • Flickr Classic
  • Blogger Classic

USA Florida. Licensed with the State of Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation, No DWE5105124 Div. of Vacation Rentals, Ch. 509, State of Florida

Copyright ©2011- 2020 ·  annamariaislandhomerental.com