Anna Maria Island Sign of the Mermaid Restaurant Review
Anna Maria Island Home Rental Logo
Sign of the Meramid Restaurant ~ Anna Maria Island



9707 Gulf Dr.
Anna Maria, FL 34216
Phone: 941.778.9399




Breakfast - $7.00

Lunch - $10.00

Dinner - $32.00



Breakfast & Lunch

Wednesday to Sunday
9:00 am - 2:00 pm



Sunday to Saturday
5:00 pm - 9:00 pm

CLOSED - We'll Let You Know if a New Restaurant Takes Over

Sign of the Mermaid is set in the cutest century-old cottage on Gulf Drive in Anna Maria. It was originally built in 1913. As soon as you climb the steps and enter this topsy-turvy restaurant, you are steeped in history.  


Their menu is well known for their seafood, steak and dessert choices. I have never been disappointed with the fine dining that abounds here. My favorite menu items are the Mermaid Baked Brie Brie wrapped in phyllo, topped with warm honey, sprinkled with toasted almonds, fresh fruit, and berries. It's decadent and worth sharing as the portion is large! The Chicken Florentine medallions are stuffed with spinach, artichoke, tomato and feta mixture with Boursin cheese, then floated on a sundried tomato and basil cream sauce. You won't be hungry for days after eating this meal. 


A little-known fact is that the Sign of the Mermaid offers breakfast and lunches from Wednesday to Sunday. During the week, the breakfast specials can't be beaten starting at $3.99.


Their pies have won the 'Best in Show' at the Crisco National Pie Championships.   

Insider Tips

Their prize-winning pies are for sale by the slice or whole. Call ahead to have them make on and pick it up to enjoy at home.

award winning pies